As Citizens Clamor for a Better Life,
Downtown Types Scheme to Take it Away
By Doug Porter
After years of suffering through cutbacks and slights of hand, residents from some of San Diego’s poorest neighborhoods packed a City Council public budget hearing last night. An event that in the past might have been focused on saving city services from further budget cuts was instead about creating positive visions and improving people’s lives.
More than 300 hundred people submitted requests to speak to Council members on topics relevant to the needs of their communities in Mayor Bob Filner’s proposed budget for FY 2014. Speakers addressed the hearing in four languages, advocating for free bus passes for needy students, a better bike infrastructure, more library hours and improvements in the way city’s taxicabs are regulated.
Although only 100 of those who signed up actually got to speak for their allotted minute, the size and determination of the groups in attendance made a clear impression on the Council.
Council President Todd Gloria Tweeted a picture of the chamber from his perspective, adding, “I’m happy to see so many San Diegans participating in #sdbudget. All the students who spoke this evening did an excellent job.”
The effort leading up to the packed council chambers was the result of grass roots organizing by the Mid City Community Advocacy Network (CAN) and the Community Budget Alliance, a coalition organized by the Center for Policy Initiatives (CPI).
The Community Budget Alliance presented a PowerPoint to the San Diego City Council with regards to the FY 2014 Proposed Budget. They also organized training sessions earlier this month on how to write and give testimony of two minutes or less during the city-council budget hearings.
KPBS came out with an online gizmo that allows users to get a feel for the complexities involved in creating and balancing the city’s $2.75 billion budget.
The budget process is far from over. Council members memos’ regarding the budget are due next Friday. The council votes in June on the budget for the fiscal year starting July 1st.
More on the ‘Movement’ to Impeach Hizzoner
The contrast between the hundreds of ordinary citizens that turned up for the budget hearings and the backroom barons seeking to maintain the status quo couldn’t be stronger, as a story in the week’s San Diego City Beat by John Lamb demonstrates.
Lamb recounts correspondence with a well-connected political source he dubs “Deep Moat” about a potential effort to mount a recall campaign aimed at unseating Mayor Bob Filner.
From City Beat:
“I think they have the money ($2 million plus) to qualify,” Deep reasoned via email. “They are just waiting to see if [Filner] gives them the ammo they need to rationalize it.”
Moat agreed the most likely candidates for “they” are the philosophically conservative Lincoln Club and local hoteliers, and the money probably isn’t sitting in some smoke-filled vault smoldering for action; rather, it likely floats in the political ether as pledges.
The website domain RecallFilner.com was registered privately in January but remains dormant, so that’s out there, for what it’s worth (as much as a bumper sticker).
Voice of San Diego did a good job recently of explaining just exactly what it would take to recall Filner and pointed out that the local law of the subject may not pass a legal sniff test.
Encinitas Yoga Trial: Some Religions Are More Equal Than Others
At a quick glance, the current court proceedings concerning the Yoga-as-physical-fitness program in the EncinitasSchool District might appear as a group of parents suffering from paranoid delusions about Hindu ninjas brainwashing their children. (Sorry, that’s as nice as I can be about describing it.)
But it turns out there’s a lot more to it. It’s not just about pushing the Yoga out. It’s about keeping a certain flavor of fundamentalist Christianity as the only option for young children.
I’m certainly not saying that all the parents participating in this lawsuit are part of this scheme, but if you look closely at the groups supporting their legal cause there’s plenty of reason to be suspicious.
The local press has carried stories over the past day or so about testimony from expert witness Dr. Candy Brown alleging that the practice of Astanga Yoga in public schools is part of a conspiracy by the Jois Foundation.
From a Fox5 News report:
The course curriculum however does not talk about religion and only uses yoga postures and deep breathing.
Dr. Brown testified she believes there’s a conspiracy at work trick students into a spiritual practice.
Judge Meyer asked for clarification, “these Jois trained instructors are just the foot soldier?”
“It’s para para – submitting to one,” Dr. Brown said.
The judge cutting her off said, “you think they have been planted in the district?”
“Well, I think that is the case, yeah,” she answered.
The lawsuit was filed by the National Center for Law and Policy on behalf of Stephen and Jennifer Sedlock, whose children attend one of the district’s nine schools. It contends that Ashtanga yoga is religious in nature and that opting out costs students’ physical education time. It asks that the program be eliminated because it violates church-state separation.
The NationalCenter for Law and Policy is a legal foundation run by an attorney named Dean Broyles, which, according to its website, defends “faith, family and freedom.” His lawsuit argues that the yoga program violates Article I, Section 4 of the California Constitution. That provision is longer than the federal constitution’s First Amendment but essentially provides for the same measure of church-state separation.
Broyles is associated with a group called the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) and makes no secret of the fact that he “has received extensive training in pro-family, pro-life and pro-religious liberty matters at ADF’s outstanding National Litigation Academies (NLA). Because of Dean’s pro-bono work, he was invited to receive special training at ADF’s advanced NLA. Dean is proud to be an ADF affiliate attorney and member of ADF’s honor guard.”
The ADF mostly plays the other side of the church-state separation issue. They’ve made it perfectly clear over the years in the full-throated defenses of Christian school groups, telling the courts, the media and the American people that separation is not a valid legal principle. They have no use for separation of church and state when they’re trying to inject fundamentalist Christianity into the public schools.
When ADF perceives to be school promotion of a religion they don’t care for, suddenly the church-state wall is their best friend. Let’s take a look at some of their interconnections. From an article posted on Alternet:
Mary Eady, one of the parents organizing against Encinitas’ yoga program, described to a Times reporter what she sees as religious content: “They’re teaching children how to meditate, how to look for peace and for comfort… It’s meant to shape the way they regulate their emotions.” She characterized the “Sun Salutation,” a basic series of yoga poses in which the student stretches his or her hands to the ceiling, as “a movement sequence that worships the sun god Surya,” and claimed that “yoga, including its physical practice, is very religious indeed.” Her legal representative, Dean Broyles, chief counsel for the Escondido-based National Center for Law & Policy, is even more adamant, asserting that the Sun Salutation constitutes sun-worship.
Eady works at a Christian organization called Truthxchange, whose chief mission is to “respond to the rising tide of neopaganism.” Her lawyer’s organization, NCPL, is an affiliate of the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF, formerly the Alliance Defense Fund), a conservative Christian legal advocacy group that has litigated on behalf of evangelical activity in schools and the broader public square. As might be imagined, the ADF takes a dim view of “neopaganism,” whatever that means to them.
The ADF and its allies also invest considerable efforts in seeking to overturn some anti-bullying school guidelines on the grounds that such policies persecute the “Christian perspective” on LGBT rights and that demanding tolerance is a front for promoting “homosexual values.” Finally, let’s consider fundamentalist Good News Clubs, which are presently in well over 3,000 public elementary schools around the country. Good News Clubs, which are sponsored by an organization called the Child Evangelism Fellowship, are ostensibly after-school “Bible study” programs that require parental permission to join. But that description is misleading. Good News Clubs are not about “study,” they are about religious indoctrination. Further, the clubs produce the false but unavoidable impression in very young children that they are part of the school; they set up shop in public school classrooms immediately after the bell rings, so as to appear a seamless part of the school day. And finally, Good News Clubs instructors tell kids attending the clubs to recruit their peers at school.
It turns out that Encinitas public elementary schools that sparked the national outcry over yoga stretching are rife with Good News Clubs: all nine public elementary schools in the district have a club, reported Assistant Superintendent Miyashiro. And their presence has been made possible by the legal firepower of the ADF and lawyers like Dean Broyles. When it comes to unhealthy entanglement between church and school, a classroom of first-graders stretching their hands to the sky seems to be, for now, a matter of far less concern than the well-organized conservative Christian proselytism that is already making deep inroads into public education.
The Child Evangelism Fellowship produces teaching materials used by the Good News Clubs. Among their stated goals is the injection of Young Earth Biblical Creationism, and fear of and contempt for science, into the public schools. And, of course, they’re also big on not-so-subtly using their lessons to “fight state laws California” which “require homosexual indoctrination for all students”.
We’re Nearly the Best When It Comes to Stress
One of the ways a city is perceived (and perceives itself) comes from the numerous surveys that inevitably lead to ‘best’ and ‘worst lists because they’re popular with the public.
Researchers with the Gallop Poll asked 350,000 Americans last year “Did you feel stressed yesterday?” as part of a much larger survey. The results for this particular question have been released as part of a Gallup-Healthways survey on daily stress levels.
And guess what? San Diego is number 5! We beat out other California cities like Sacramento and San Francisco, along with metropolises like Houston and Miami in other parts of the country. Here’s a cool graphic from Huffpo showing our awesomeness at stress.
But we’re gonna have to work harder this year to beat out Los Angeles, which topped list. Maybe we can just cut back on the craft beer a little bit….
On This Day: 1900 – Civil War hero Sgt. William H. Carney became the first African American to receive the Medal of Honor, 37 years after the Battle of Fort Wagner. 1934 – In Bienville Parish, LA, Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow were ambushed and killed by Texas Rangers. The bank robbers were riding in a stolen Ford Deluxe. 1979 – “The Kids Are Alright,” Jeff Stein’s documentary compilation of film clips detailing the history of the Who, debuted in New York.
Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe to “The Starting Line” and get an email every time a new article in this series is posted!
I read the Daily Fishwrap(s) so you don’t have to… Catch “the Starting Line” Monday thru Friday right here at San Diego Free Press (dot) org. Send your hate mail and ideas to DougPorter@SanDiegoFreePress.Org Check us out on Facebook and Twitter.
Anna Daniels says
Last nights budget hearing went from 6pm to 9pm. The first hour and a half was devoted to other agenda items. That was unfortunate, and I am not convinced at the moment that it was excusable. The testimony on the budget didn’t begin until 7:30. Needless to say, it was a very long night for young and old alike.
Mayor Filner was there to address the council, which was a clear break with the Sanders tradition. The City does not provide translating services/equipment (!) so the Environmental Health Coalition stepped in to provide them.
My favorite “Let them eat cake moment” occurred during the discussion initiated by Councilwoman Zapf about the disappearance of the Mission Trails Park Day Campground funding from the budget, and Filner’s allocation of those funds for the free mid-city bus passes. Neither she nor Councilman Sherman were happy about this. One of them, I think it was Zapf, said that mid-city youth should go to the day campground. Unfortunately, the proposed bus passes are for kids in families with no cars…
Frank Gormlie says
Thanks Anna, for being part of the citizens’ delegation.
Just to toot a plot we have uncovered over at the OB Rag, see this:
(SATIRE) Ocean Beach Lifeguard Statute Is a Secret Republican Plot to Hold City Council Seat – http://obrag.org/?p=74053
La Playa Heritage says
On March 11, 2013 as Item S-400 Fiscal Year 2013 Mid-Year Budget Revisions, Mayor Filner recommended a $240,00 increase to Park and Recreation’s Budget to support Mission Trails Regional Park, Kumeyaay Campground, and Visitors Center; $500,000 for a Balboa Park Traffic Management Plan, and other line items.
The March Mid-Year FY-2013 Budget Revisions came out a month before the TMD issue was resolved in mid-April 2013.
On the advice of the Independent Budget Analyst (IBA), the City Council voted to exclude the $240,000 for the Mission Trails Campground, a Park Ranger, and a Recreation Center Director. Probably out of spite for the TMD mess.
It was classic when Councilpersons Zapf and Sherman complained that there was no funding budgeted in FY-2014 for Mission Trails. In response it was pointed out they, the City Council, just denial the line item 2 months earlier in March.
Andy Cohen says
Interesting addendum: When I interviewed Filner a couple of months back during the TMD mess he shared this little tidbit with me: He or someone on his staff (he didn’t specify who) caught Joe Terzi, the CEO of the Tourism Authority, putting a “Recall Filner” sticker on the mayor’s city vehicle. I was a little taken aback when he said it.
So there you have it. At least one indicator of who is behind the recall effort, such as it is.
Jay Powell says
My goodness, Mr. Terzi pulls down a pretty hefty paycheck for leading this City of San Diego-sanctioned special district. I think there is actually a law prohibiting putting a sticker on someone’s car without their permission– much less vandalizing an official city vehicle. But, then again, considering the shenanigans in the Fourth District election over the past week with Mr. Remer reprinting one of his worst hit pieces ( I hope Councilmember-elect Cole at least got a discount on that job) its kinda really, business as usual in “the biggest little town in California” where the political m.o. is still “high school with money”.
micaela shafer porte says
thank you for being the voice of the people… i LOVE your perspectives…
THANKS to Y’ALL there is a new feeling around in town…
Professor Mayor Filner: be strong, hang loose, whatever you need…go for it!
sdfp press peeps, yur the best,
people of san diego, stand tall, this is our future, and we’re making it…
keep up the good works,