Survey says nearly three fourths of the population thinks the GOP’s tactic is a bad idea
Yes, that’s the real cover
By Doug Porter
The crapola has hit the fanola. Eight hundred thousand Americans are officially furloughed. Another million or so are being asked to come to work without pay.
Why? Because Congress passed a health care law after debating it for 18 months. The President signed the law. The Supreme Court (mostly) upheld the Constitutionality of the law. And now a group of three dozen or so extremists in the House of Representatives say “no way”.
With substantive financial backing from another three dozen or so big money donors, these extremist Republicans are threatening their own party members with reprisals should they not accede to their demands.
A straight up or down vote to continue government operations would, by all accounts, pass both chambers of Congress. In the meantime, Congress gets paid, even if they have to get their own towels in the gym and the gift shop is closed down.
Yet the Daily Fishwrap in San Diego calls the shutdown of the federal government a failure of leadership on the part of the President. Using the talking points being promulgated by Fox news, they say that a President who’s willing to negotiate with Iran and Russia ought to be willing to at least talk to Congress.
Fox News’ Sean Hannity repeated the recent Fox talking point that President Obama was willing to negotiate with Iran, Syria, and other foreign actors, but refused to even speak with Republican members of Congress. In fact, the president has repeatedly emphasized his willingness to negotiate and recently spoke with Speaker of the House John Boehner (R-OH) and other congressional leaders. via Media Matters
Maybe, as the Daily Show’s Jon Stewart noted last night, it’s the Republicans who, by comparison with the Iranians and the Russians, are unreasonable.
Today’s UT-San Diego editorial also repeats the GOP fantasy that the Affordable Care Act is about to “collapse under its unworkable weight”. If that’s true, shouldn’t they just let it happen? Could another Democrat get elected for President in the foreseeable future if that’s true?
Today’s paper also features a predictable “poll”. A plurality say it’s the President’s fault. The question of whether or not the government should be shut down isn’t even asked.
Bloomberg News, which has considerably more credibility and resources, also has a poll, one that asks the relevant questions:
In a rejection of congressional Republicans’ strategy, Americans overwhelmingly oppose undermining President Barack Obama’s health-care law by shutting down the federal government or resisting an increase in the nation’s debt limit, according to a poll released today.
By 72 percent to 22 percent, Americans oppose Congress “shutting down major activities of the federal government” as a way to stop the Affordable Care Act from going into effect, the national survey from Quinnipiac University found.
By 64 percent to 27 percent, voters don’t want Congress to block an increase in the nation’s $16.7 trillion federal borrowing limit as a way to thwart implementation of the health-care law, which Obama signed into law in 2010 with a goal of insuring millions of Americans, known as “Obamacare.”
A majority of the public, 58 percent, is opposed to cutting off funding for the insurance program that begins enrollment today. Thirty-four percent support defunding it.
The Affordable Care Act Rolls Out
As of this morning millions of Americans who are unable to get insurance through their workplace will have access to a variety of health plans at affordable prices. They’ll be able to shop through insurance marketplaces that allow consumers to compare plans side by side along with pricing.
For the first time health plans must meet new basic standards and companies are prohibited from turning away consumers with preexisting medical conditions. Low- and moderate-income people who make less than four times the federal poverty level — or about $46,000 — will qualify for government subsidies to help with their premiums.
The United States will become the last industrialized nation in the world to offer its citizens affordable access to healthcare. Obamacare may not be perfect (I still advocate for a single payer system), but it’s 100% better than any GOP plan that’s made it past the press conference stage.
From today’s LA Times:
Three and a half years after President Obama signed his landmark healthcare law, his administration made its final preparations Monday to begin enrolling millions of Americans in health insurance amid persistent anxiety over possible technical problems and intense opposition from Republican critics.
Administration officials emphasized that a government shutdown would not prevent the federal website for enrolling in health coverage — http://www.healthcare.gov — from going live at 8 a.m Eastern time Tuesday, allowing consumers to begin signing up for plans.
Officials in most states that are running their own online insurance marketplaces — including California, Connecticut and Maryland — are also planning to open for business Tuesday. And call centers set up to handle consumer questions through the government’s 1-800-318-2596 hotline are scheduled to be open for business.
“The Affordable Care Act is moving forward,” Obama told reporters at the White House on Monday. “You can’t shut it down.”
From today’s Washington Post:
People seeking to buy health insurance on the federal marketplace will be able to enter personal information, including their incomes and Social Security numbers; learn how much government assistance they might qualify for, if any; search for plans by price and coverage level; and then purchase a plan directly from the insurance company.
But Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, in a briefing with reporters, pleaded for patience, acknowledging there would probably be some glitches in the coming days and weeks as the administration moves forward on the sweeping program known as Obamacare. She likened the inevitable fixes to software updates on Apple products such as the iPhone or iPad.
The chatter coming out of Washington DC is that this government shut down will last for a week or more. The President is reportedly canceling a diplomatic trip to Asia. And coming up behind this current stalemate is a deadline for raising the debt limit ceiling on or about October 17th. GOP obstinacy lasting that long could seriously endanger the economic and political future of the country, as Paul Krugman explains in today’sNew York Times:
So how does this end? The votes to fund the government and raise the debt ceiling are there, and always have been: every Democrat in the House would vote for the necessary measures, and so would enough Republicans. The problem is that G.O.P. leaders, fearing the wrath of the radicals, haven’t been willing to allow such votes. What would change their minds?
Ironically, considering who got us into our economic mess, the most plausible answer is that Wall Street will come to the rescue — that the big money will tell Republican leaders that they have to put an end to the nonsense.
But what if even the plutocrats lack the power to rein in the radicals? In that case, Mr. Obama will either let default happen or find some way of defying the blackmailers, trading a financial crisis for a constitutional crisis.
This all sounds crazy, because it is. But the craziness, ultimately, resides not in the situation but in the minds of our politicians and the people who vote for them. Default is not in our stars, but in ourselves.
Do yourselves and the country a favor. Pick up the phone, send an email, send a snail mail.
Tomorrow I promise a more “local” column. This stuff (the gov’t shutdown) was all I could think about this morning.
Coming Soon, The SDFP Special Election Voters Guide
SD Free Press will be covering all 11 candidates starting later this week, starting with basic profiles. We’ll offer a portal where all our stories on this election, plus significant stories from other media outlets, can be accessed by voters interested in learning more about the candidates. And yes, we’ll get around to telling you what we think of it all.
On This Day: 1908 – The Model T automobile was introduced by Henry Ford. The purchase price of the car was $850. 1964 – The Free Speech Movement was started at the University of California at Berkeley. 1995 – Nearly $1 million was raised at the Farm Aid concert in Louisville, KY. The musicians that performed were Willie Nelson, Neil Young, John Mellencamp, Hootie and the Blowfish, and The Dave Matthews Band
Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe to “The Starting Line” and get an email every time a new article in this series is posted!
I read the Daily Fishwrap(s) so you don’t have to… Catch “the Starting Line” Monday thru Friday right here at San Diego Free Press (dot) org. Send your hate mail and ideas to DougPorter@
Doug Porter
Latest posts by Doug Porter (see all)
- Last Call. Last Column. - December 14, 2018
- Which Presidential Candidate Will You Support in 2020? - December 13, 2018
- Mounting the Assault on Big Gay and Other Drivel From SDSU’s Minimum Wage Scrooge - December 12, 2018
Nihilists. Saboteurs. & the Republican loonies are cheering on the shutdown. In the words of the great Charlie Pierce over at Esquire:
“We have elected an ungovernable collection of snake-handlers, Bible-bangers, ignorami, bagmen and outright frauds, a collection so ungovernable that it insists the nation be ungovernable, too. We have elected people to govern us who do not believe in government.”
For a serious number of Republicans, shutting down the federal government has been a tactic since Newt Gingrich and Dick Armey did it back in the 90s. They did it back then and have done it again, most of them, on the theory that the short shutdown will demonstrate we don’t need federal employees.
The tactic is only made possible by a national press made neurotic by a fear of appearing partial to liberalism that it quickly resorts to blaming Congressional gridlock in its headlines (even though polls show voters blame the Republicans), and we have to read stories which quote Tea Party fanatics who claim the Democrats won’t negotiate (the repeal of legislation passed three years ago). NBC’s chief political correspondent can even deny that correcting political lies is not in his job description. All this enforced neutrality in the face of sabotage and money-fueled fraud is designed to break down people’s belief in a federal government.
Free market Randys, redneck gun freaks, know-nothing immigrant bashers, and hungry bankers, have forged a temporary alliance to limit the federal government to a police force. They remain a minority, an increasingly desperate one, even if this is the third time they’ve attempted a government shutdown.
Because of the shutdown I was unable to email or call Reid or White House. I was able to leave a message with Boehner (202) 225-0600
Today also the 123rd birthday of Yosemite National Park (1890), which – as many news accounts are noting – has the occasion solely to itself, since all national parks (including NPS-run websites) closed by the shutdown. Not fun blowing out your own birthday candles when there’s no one there to cheer…
Bless Google, though, for remembering; they put out a really cool Doodle to honor Half Dome Central on its big day!
FYI: Cabrillo National Monument’s 100th birthday is only some 2 weeks away. Must Old Point Loma Light be the Lonely Lighthouse?