By Jennifer Raff / Violent Metaphors
In light of recent outbreaks of measles and other vaccine preventable illnesses, and the refusal of anti-vaccination advocates to acknowledge the problem, I thought it was past time for this post.
You are being lied to. The people who claim to be acting in the best interests of your children are putting their health and even lives at risk.
They say that measles isn’t a deadly disease.
But it is.
They say that chickenpox isn’t that big of a deal.
But it can be.
They say that the flu isn’t dangerous.
But it is.
They say that whooping cough isn’t so bad for kids to get.
But it is.
They say that vaccines aren’t that effective at preventing disease.
But 3 million children’s lives are saved every year by vaccination, and 2 million die every year from vaccine-preventable illnesses.
They say that “natural infection” is better than vaccination.
But they’re wrong.
They say that vaccines haven’t been rigorously tested for safety.
But vaccines are subjected to a higher level of scrutiny than any other medicine. For example, this study tested the safety and effectiveness of the pneumococcal vaccine in more than 37,868 children.
They will say that doctors won’t admit there are any side effects to vaccines.
But the side effects are well known, and except in very rare cases quite mild.
They say that the MMR vaccine causes autism.
It doesn’t. (The question of whether vaccines cause autism has been investigated in study after study, and they all show overwhelming evidence that they don’t.)
They say that thimerosal in vaccines causes autism.
It doesn’t, and it hasn’t been in most vaccines since 2001 anyway.
They say that the aluminum in vaccines (an adjuvant, or component of the vaccine designed to enhance the body’s immune response) is harmful to children.
But children consume more aluminum in natural breast milk than they do in vaccines, and far higher levels of aluminum are needed to cause harm.
They say that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (and/or the “vaccine court”) proves that vaccines are harmful.
They say that the normal vaccine schedule is too difficult for a child’s immune system to cope with.
They say that if other people’s children are vaccinated, there’s no need for their children to get vaccinated.
This is one of the most despicable arguments I’ve ever heard. First of all, vaccines aren’t always 100% effective, so it is possible for a vaccinated child to still become infected if exposed to a disease. Worse, there are some people who can’t receive vaccinations, because they are immune deficient, or because they are allergic to some component. Those people depend upon herd immunity to protect them. People who choose not to vaccinate their children against infectious diseases are putting not only their own children at risk, but also other people’s children.
They say that ‘natural’, ‘alternative’ remedies are better than science-based medicine.
The truth is that vaccines are one of our greatest public health achievements, and one of the most important things you can do to protect your child.
I can predict exactly the sort of response I will be getting from the anti-vaccine activists. Because they can’t argue effectively against the overwhelming scientific evidence about vaccines, they will say that I work for Big Pharma. (I don’t and never have). They will say that I’m not a scientist (I am),and that I’m an “Agent 666” (I don’t know what that is, but I’m pretty sure that I’m not one).
None of these things are true, but they are the reflexive response by the anti-vaccine activists because they have no facts to back up their position. On some level, deep down, they must understand this, and are afraid of the implications, so they attack the messenger.
Why are they lying to you? Some are doing it for profit, trying to sell their alternative remedies by making you afraid of science-based medicine. I’m sure that many others within the anti-vaccine movement have genuinely good intentions, and do honestly believe that vaccines are harmful. But as a certain astrophysicist recently said “The good thing about science is that it’s true whether or not you believe in it”. In the case of vaccine truthers, this is not a good thing. Good intentions will not prevent microbes from infecting and harming people, and the message that vaccines are dangerous is having dire consequences. There are outbreaks of vaccine-preventable illnesses now throughout the United States because of unvaccinated children.
In only one respect is my message the same as the anti-vaccine activists: Educate yourself. But while they mean “Read all these websites that support our position”, I suggest you should learn what the scientific community says. Learn how the immune system works. Go read about the history of disease before vaccines, and talk to older people who grew up when polio, measles, and other diseases couldn’t be prevented. Go read about how vaccines are developed, and how they work. Read about Andrew Wakefield, and how his paper that claimed a link between the MMR vaccine and autism has been withdrawn, and his medical license has been revoked. Read the numerous, huge studies that have explicitly examined whether autism is caused by the vaccine…and found nothing. (While you’re at it, read about the ongoing research to determine what IS the cause—or causes —ofautism, which is not helped by people continuing to insist that vaccines cause it).
That may seem like a lot of work, and scientific papers can seem intimidating to read. But reading scientific articles is a skill that can be mastered. Here’s a great resource for evaluating medical information on the internet, and I wrote a guide for non-scientists on how to read and understand the scientific literature. You owe it to your children, and to yourself, to thoroughly investigate the issue. Don’t rely on what some stranger on the internet says (not even me!). Read the scientific studies that I linked to in this post for yourself, and talk to your pediatricians. Despite what the anti-vaccine community is telling you, you don’t need to be afraid of the vaccines. You should instead be afraid of what happens without them.
Edited to add: This video is an outstanding summary of many of these issues. I encourage you to watch it.
Jennifer Raff studies the genomes of modern and ancient peoples in order to uncover details of human prehistory. You can learn more about her scientific publications and credentials here and here. She’s also a martial artist, currently training (and occasionally competing) in Muay Thai, boxing, BJJ, and MMA.
Those who rail against vaccinations apparently put their faith in a power much higher than scientific certainty. It’s probably not a stretch to say that satiating their extreme appetites takes precendence over the true needs of their young.
As a non-medical professional, non-practicing vegetarian and out of practice hippie, the odds are overwhelmingly in my kids’ favor sticking with science rather than any of their half-baked alarmist ideas.
Boy, those last two sentences just say it all. Thanks, and congratulations, SDFP – this perspective is so rarely found elsewhere. If I didn’t have SDFP, I wouldn’t be otherwise inundated with fear-inducing histeria opinion pieces about the dangers of non-fatal diseases. Sarcasm aside, I’m very disappointed that you have decided to jump on the bandwagon and join in attempting to crush a minority position without even giving voice to the other side. We hear from plenty of Jennifer Raff’s in the mainstream – you are supposed to be non-corporate, non-propagandist. I know for a fact there are plenty of people in San Diego who have unanswered questions about vaccines that are not addressed in her article or in any of its links. These are intelligent people want to learn about vaccines, and vaccine-decliners probably know a lot more about vaccines and disease than the vast majority of people who blindly trust our profit-based “healthcare” system which can’t even be entrusted to safely oversee normal human processes, such as birth. These vaccine crusaders refer to the CDC as if its merits are unquestionable, as if government agencies are beyond reproach and independent from the influence of the profit motive. Autism is far from the only concern about vaccines. I haven’t seen a single response here or elsewhere to a plethora of concerns that vaccine questioners / decliners have, including, for example, evidence that a rapid decline in polio had begun prior to the introduction of vaccines. What is the response? If anyone has this information, please do share it, but please don’t just repeat others – if you haven’t heard the other side, don’t jump in the debate.
I’m really not sure about the dangers. But why should I do something just because the experts tell me I have to? Yes, there are wackos in the anti-vax world. But I’d rather be a paranoid wacko than a stupid doormat who unquestionably accepts whatever the mass media tells us is 100% A-OK. Such as: GMOs, thalidomide, cesarian sections, agent orange, asbestos, Bisphenol-A, fluoridated water… morning sickness gotcha down? Have a cigarette! Humankind or mother nature – which is more dangerous to humans? Gee, after familiarizing myself with our pristine history of chemicals, medicine, etc., you know what? I think I’ll take my chances with the latter. I’d rather die or lose family to the elements/flora/fauna than allow myself to be frightened into voluntarily administering some crap cocktail concocted by Uncle Sam and Auntie Capital.
Focus, WH. Thalidomide and cesarian sections (sic) have nothing whatsoever to do with vaccines. Agent Orange should not be confused with vaccination in a clear mind. So you are good with getting sick or losing family members; you may well get to experience that avoidable destiny. The suffering won’t be caused by whatever you imagine “elements” to be, but by your stubborn paranoid fear of CDC or Auntie Capital while rejecting the specificity of science. Your wild denial of facts as sure as the earth is not flat becomes a serious problem because you put the rest of us at risk, whether you believe it or not. You are clearly already frightened. Try to calm down so you can separate fact from fear.